The wanting never went away. What went away was your willingness to be destroyed by it — to lose an entire Tuesday to a Monday night that seemed perfectly reasonable at the time. Nobody was building the party for that person.
So somebody did. Doors at nine, last call at one, aimed squarely at people who never stopped loving a good record and simply outgrew the two-in-the-morning version of loving it. The format stays loose: vinyl-only some nights, vinyl-mostly on others, occasionally a live set, always a playlist somebody actually thought about. The crowd runs largely thirties, people who learned to dance to the right records and never quit — they just moved the whole thing earlier.
Music Box on a Friday is the correct room for this, a downtown space that books touring acts most other nights of the week. Cover at the door.
Bring the friend who keeps announcing they are too old for this. Watch them stay till last call.